Eastern Regional Jam's Whimsical Halloween Trick Tradition in Shepherdstown
‘Just the trick’: Eastern Regional Jam becomes known for humorous Halloween tradition
The Shepherdstown Chronicle | Thursday, November 6, 2025
By Staff
In Shepherdstown, local band Eastern Regional Jam has embraced a humorous Halloween tradition by distributing unconventional 'tricks' instead of candy to trick-or-treaters. This year, members handed out items like potatoes, radishes, and even cat food, delighting those with a sense of humor, particularly older students from Shepherd University. This quirky practice began three years ago when Todd Cotgreave gave away random donations instead of candy, offering a unique spin on the holiday that remains popular despite the abundance of traditional treats in nearby areas. The Shepherdstown Chronicle highlights this fun twist on a time-honored tradition within the community.